John's Birthday

"What are you going to do about it?" John asked.

"I won't give you your surprise." Cassie replied.

"That's just being mean." John said.

"You started it." Cassie said.

"I did not, you did." John said.

"No, no, it was all you." Cassie said, waiting by the car.

"Nope and I'm the birthday boy you're supposed to let me win." John said.

Cassie playfully rolled her eyes. "Okay, fine, you win. Just open up the damn car, so that we can get home and I give you your surprise." She chuckled.

"Fine, bossy." John said with a chuckle as he unlocked the car then got in.

Cassie laughed as she got into the car and put her seatbelt on.

John started the car then drove home.

Cassie smiled and looked out the window. She was excited tonight was going to be perfect.

John smiled back before he focused on the road. He was greatful for Cassie. He knew had she not have been there it probably would have been a shitty birthday. Ten minutes later John parked in the driveway of his home then got out.

"I'll meet you in the living room a bit. Your gift is upstairs, relax." Cassie said, she leaned over to kiss John on the cheek before she got out of the car. She used her to key to get into the house and from there she walked upstairs to go get her "surprise" ready.

John nodded then chuckled before he got out of the car. He walked into the house before he walked into the living room and sat down on the couch.

Cassie dressed in a black lingerie and heels. She checked herself in the mirror before she walked downstairs.

"Close your eyes!" She yelled before she walked into the living room. She was nervous as she eventually stood in front of John whose eyes were closed, but she knew this would be right. She sighed before she spoke again, "Okay you can open them.." She smiled at John and then straddled his lap. "Happy Birthday.." She said before she kissed him.

John opened his eyes widely in shock. He then pushed Cassie off him and onto the couch. His intention wasn't to hurt her, just to get her off of him.

"What the fuck are you doing?!" John yelled as he stood up.

Cassie looked up at John surprised by his reaction. "I was giving you your birthday present." Cassie said, she got over from the shock and wrapped her arms around his neck. "I'm making up for Elle not being here."

John moved away from Elle.

"This isn't what I was hoping for when you said the word surprise." John said with an angry tone in his voice.

Cassie bit her lip and looked down, acting embarrassed. This was NOT going according to plan. She had one more trick up her sleeve that HAD to work. But for now, she'd have to play this off.

"I'm so..so..sorry...I...uh..." She said. "...so embarrassed." She whispered. "Look...I can't apologize enough. Just...how about you go upstairs and get some rest. I promise I'll be out of the house by the time you wake up tomorrow." She said before she walked past him to go upstairs. She didn't want to resort to this, she wanted John to want her for her, but if she had to, she'd pretend to be Elle just to get him worked up enough to where he HAD to give into her, then he'd realize they were meant to be together. He wouldn't be able to tell the difference right away in the dark, right?

"You fucking better be. Elle was right about you." John said before he stormed upstairs to his room and slammed the door shut.

Once in his room he took off his clothes then got into bed. He couldn't believe how this day's gone, first his wife forgets about his birthday then Cassie kisses him. It all just sucked.

Elle was right about you. That stung. But in her mind, John was just acting out of anger. That dumb bitch was brainwashing him. She knew John meant every single word that he said to her before this, Elle was just getting into this mind. That was okay though, she'd forgive him for this and wouldn't let it get to her.

This would all work out. She acted like she was leaving, even walking out of the house to keep the act going. But thirty minutes later, she walked back. "John!" She yelled in a voice that similar to Elle's. She knew she wouldn't be able to imitate Elle's voice that much so needed to act quickly. Cassie headed back upstairs and went into John's room. She didn't open the door all the way, in case John was still awake and slipped inside. She went over to the bed and got on top of them. "I'm so sorry..." She said softly before she began to kiss his neck.

"Elle, you forgot my birthday and you think that's going to make it alright?" John asked.

"Ssshhh...." Cassie said as she began to nip and kiss at his neck. Her hands roamed around his body and she couldn't help the moan that came out, loving the way her fingers felt on him.

John moaned at the pleasure he was receiving then moved his hands to rub Cassie's back, not knowing it wasn't Elle.